When must a party express any new matters of law or fact in their pleadings?

A party must express any new matters of law or fact in their pleadings at the time of making a denial. This requirement ensures that all relevant issues are clearly articulated and that the opposing party is made aware of all claims and defenses at an early stage in the proceedings.

When a party denies an allegation, it is an opportunity to respond not just by refuting the claim but also to assert any counterarguments or new facts that could potentially change the landscape of the dispute. This is important because it helps both parties and the court identify the actual points of contention early on, facilitating a more efficient legal process.

In contrast, matters expressed only in the final statement of the case might come too late to be effectively considered, while new information raised during a reply could disrupt the flow of the proceedings, as the reply is meant to address issues already pleaded. Similarly, private discussions with the judge should not include new matters that could affect the case's outcome, as they need to be formally presented in the pleadings for transparency and fairness to all parties involved.